What’s your opinion of Marty’s behavior?

lie

Is it wrong for Marty to keep Judd’s poaching (killing deer out of season) a secret, so that he can keep Shiloh?  Why or why not?  Explain your opinion.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized by Mrs. Ngai. Bookmark the permalink.

About Mrs. Ngai

My name is Mrs. Ngai and I am currently a 5th grade teacher in the Math, Science, Technology Magnet at Montara Elementary School. I love using technology in the classroom and am really excited about using this blog with my students! In addition to technology, I also love chocolate, traveling, learning new languages, and trying new food from many different cultures!

9 thoughts on “What’s your opinion of Marty’s behavior?

  1. I think it is not ok to lie because if you lie you think you will not get in trouble but sooner or later your parents will find out then you will get in trouble

  2. Well its always never good to lie but Marty doing it in a good way because hes lies to save a abused dog. And Marty starves and takes chances to save Shiloh plus in the cause that Marty in lies to save a dog. I guess thats a good reason to lie but Marty feels bad that he lies to his parents but he loves Shiloh so i say its ok to lie. In his Shoes HE LOVES A DOG AND HE WILL DO ANYTHING TO SAVE AND PROTECT HIM!

  3. I think that in this case it is good to lie because Marty will do anything for Shiloh because he loves him to death and will do anything to protect him.😍😍😍😍😍😚😚😚😘😘But also what Marty is doing isn’t lying…it is lying by omission.😉

  4. I think it is wrong,but at the same time yes. The reason I think it’s wrong because yeah he wants Shiloh,hut it is his responsibility to tell the game warden about Judd. The game warden would’ve made Judd face his consequences for his actions.

    At the same time it is a little all right because he’s doing all this for Shiloh, and that is really sweet for him. 🙂 😉

  5. I think it’s not wrong because since Marty want Shiloh he could just have the deer secret out and that way he could keep Shiloh. I know Marty wants Shiloh and wants to keep the secret because Marty really cares about Shiloh and Marty loves Shiloh.

  6. I think it’s it wrong for Marty to keep Judd’s poaching a secret because even though we read the story and we know what happened, Judd could have still gotten away with it and kill more does or more deer out of season.

  7. what i think about telling a lie is that lets just say that u have to tell a lie like if they would do something bad to u but other than that don’t tell a lie because it might make some thing happen to the other person u don’t want to be mean just be honest and some thing good will happen to u

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *